A Study of Answer Changing Behavior in MC Tests: The Effect of the Academic Course, Field of Study, Gender and Teachers’ Attitude

Document Type: Research Paper

Author

Shiraz University

Abstract

This study investigated the answer changing behavior of the Iranian university students and its relationship to the academic course, gender, and field of study. 362 students at the University of Isfahan took part in the study. 76 English language teachers were also surveyed for their attitude toward answer changing on MC tests. The results indicated that 42.11% of the teachers had a negative attitude toward answer changing as they believed that the first answer selected is intuitively the best one and should not be changed. The results also indicated that answer changing would basically have positive effects on the total test scores. It was found that 63.09% of the answer changes were beneficial (from Wrong to Right choices). In contrast, 15.18% of the answer changes were negative (from Right to Wrong options), and 21.73% had no effect on the test scores (from Wrong to Wrong options). As for the effect of gender, no significant difference was found between males and females. Concerning the effect of academic course, the only significant difference lay in the number of Right to Wrong changes. Finally, it was found that field of study would make a difference only when Right to Wrong changes were considered. 

Keywords


Al-Hamly, M., & Coombe, C. (2005). To change or not to change: Investigating the value of MCQ answer changing for Gulf Arab students. Language Testing, 22 (4), 509-531.

Balance, C. (1977). Students’ expectations and other answer changing behavior. Psychological Reports, 41, 163-166.

Bath, J. (1967). Answer-changing behavior on objective examinations. The Journal of Educational Research, 6, 105-107.

Bauer, D., Kopp, V., & Fischer, M. (2007). Answer changing in multiple choice assessment change that answer when in doubt-and spread the word. BMC Medical Education, 7:28. doi:10.1186/1472-6920-7-28.

Benjamin, L. T., Cavell T. A., & Shallenberger, W. R.  (1984). Staying with initial answers on objective tests – Is it a myth?. Teaching of Psychology, 11, 133-141.

Foote, R., & Belinky, C. (1972). It pays to switch? Consequences of changing answers on multiple-choice examinations. Psychological Reports, 31, 667-673.

Friedman, S., & Cook, G. (1995). Is an examinee’s cognitive style related to the impact of answer changing on multiple choice tests?. Journal of Experimental Education, 63, 199-213.

Friedman-Erickson, S. (1994). To change or not to change: The multiple choice dilemma. Paper presented at the annual institute of the American Psychological Society on the Teaching of Psychology, Washington, DC.

Geiger, M. (1991a). Changing multiple choice answers: A validation and extension. College Student Journal, 25, 181-186.

Green, K. (1981). Item-answer changes on multiple choice tests as a function of test anxiety. Journal of Experimental Education, 49, 225-228.

Heidenberg, A. J., & Layne, B. H. (2000). Answer changing: A conditional argument. College Student Journal, 34(3), 440-450.

Kusler, D. (1988). Teaching students how to take an examination. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 14, 190-191.

Lynch, D. O., & Smith, B. C. (1972, April). To change or not to change item answers when taking tests: Empirical evidence for test takers. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL.

Mercer, M. (1979, April). Answer changing and students’ test scores. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, CA.

Pascale, P. (1974). Changing initial answers on multiple choice achievement tests. Measurement and Evaluation in Guidance, 6, 236-238.

Payne, B. D. (1984). The relationship of test anxiety and answer-changing behavior: An analysis by race and sex. Measurement and Evaluation in Guidance, 16(4), 205-210.

Penfield, D., & Mercer, M. (1980). Answer changing and statistics. Educational Research Quarterly, 5, 50-57.

Ramsey, P., Ramsey, P. P., & Barnes, M. J. (1987). Effects of student confidence and item difficulty on test score gains due to answer changing. Teaching of Psychology, 144, 206-210.

Reile, P., & Briggs, L. (1952). Should students change their initial answers on objective-type tests? More evidence regarding an old problem. Journal of Educational Psychology, 43, 110-115.

Skinner, N. (1983). Switching answers on multiple-choice questions: Shrewdness or shibboleth?. Teaching of Psychology, 14, 241-242.

Stough, L. (1993, April). Research on multiple-choice questions: Implications for strategy instruction. Paper presented at the annual convention of the Council for Exceptional Children, San Antonio, TX.

Vidler, D., & Hansen, R. (1980). Answer changing on multiple-choice tests. Journal of Experimental Education, 49, 18-20.

Waddell, D. L., &Blankenship,J. C. (1994). Answer changing:A meta-analysis of the prevalence and patterns. The Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, 25(4), 155-158.